Re: "Something cannot come from nothing" - different refutat #81 by Rumraket Oct 18, 2010 8:18 pm VazScep wrote : Nothing can replace god as creator of the universe. We cannot afford large tax cuts, which are pleasing to propose (something for nothing) but involve long-term risks that are not understood by the president or, to be fair, by economists. Troy (aka Youtube user Parture) from Edmonton, Alberta (Canada) tries to prove the existence of God with the argument that something cannot come from nothing, as popularized by Christian apologists like William Lane Craig. It will be over 30 days. The rays of the setting sun, sprinkled from the sky, causing the scattered and disordered buildings around them to be shrouded in a yellow halo of light shaking. But atheists are trapped, because nothing is all they are left with. Leif Harrison has entered the world of the Hemp business after a multi-varied work experience in both high-level corporate business and post US Navy career. Cycles from almost nothing. Newer Than: Search this thread only; Search this forum only. Display results as threads What were the arguments that ancient philosophers gave for the principle ex nihilo nihilo fit? Hamann and Friedrich Jacobi both emphasized that faith penetrates our being so much that it cannot be ontologically severed; and Heidegger, though somewhat more coy about his theological debts, was doing something similar by trying to disclose the fundamental ontological disposition of Dasein. Asked by: Rob Answer The law you cite, applies only to 'closed systems', i.e. [N]othingness is the highest entropy state around -- you can shuffle it around all you want and it still looks like nothing. Given this law, it is hard to see how nothing could ever be turned into something, let alone something as big as the universe." What kind of system is nothing? C. Therefore, if a quantum fluctuation occurs, then it is something not nothing. The wristwatch that I wear on my left arm did not just happen all by itself, someone had to build it. Scriptures: 2 Kings 6:8 (Syria is at war with Israel). Comments for Something Can't Come from Nothing. Something Cannot Come From Nothing and Be So Perfectly Fine Tuned.
Even our greatest scientific understanding of the Universe has a god-like narrative where everything comes from the Big Bang expanding from condensed matter. Is that entity the Universe or the Creator, is a different topic and a different question. 60 reviews of Fountains at Palmdale "I have lived at the Fountain at Palmdale Apartment complex for three years now. 3. If that's the case, there has never been, in the entire history of time, a "nothing" for something to come out of. Therefore, our first choice is answered. In his presentation, Msgr. 4. 7. In other words, something cannot come from nothing. Blood Pressure Is High Even With Medicine. Given the First Law of Thermodynamics: that you can't get something from nothing. This is a given according to physical science, common sense, and everyday experience. P2. Thich Nhat Hanh and 80 monks and nuns began the public talk with a ceremony to send the energy of peace and compassion to all those who were suffering from the events of September those who had passed away and those who were presently struggling where nothing can be added or subtracted from the 'specimen'. So, it is trivially true that a thing cannot come from nothing. Discussion in 'Philosophy' started by Et Cetera, Jul 14, 2009. That much is certain. Nothing will come of nothing is a quote from William Shakespeares tragedy King Lear. There three leading possibilities for how this excess of matter over antimatter could have emerged: New physics at the electroweak scale could greatly enhances the amount of C - We know that money doesnt just appear. That conflicts with this claim. Et Cetera thread killa. We can turn to five of historys most influential philosophers for wisdom, and maybe solace, as we meet our maker, writes Steven Luper. I speak the truth, not my fill of it, but as much as I dare speak; and I dare to do so a little more as I grow old. To truly answer the question of how something could arise from nothing, we would need to explain the quantum state of the entire universe at the beginning of the Planck epoch. Nothing as an actual ontological existent (that is, it actually exists outside of the mind and without a mind). Something From Nothing. My father who is a mechanical engineer seems to think that something cannot come from nothing but I think that he is wrong because my father evidently never heard of virtual particles and quantum field theory. 2 Kings 6:1324 (A famine caused people to be desperate for food). 2 Kings 6:2530 (The of Israel hears a woman crying because she ate her son). We choose our words carefully to convey our perspective. A cloud cannot come from nothing, so before being a cloud, it must have been something else: water in the ocean, heat from the sun, et cetera. I need to unlock my green dot wall let MASTER card. Yes, nothing can produce something; so no God is necessary for the production of the universe. 2. No, nothing can't produce something, so God -- if he exists -- cannot have been 'produced' by nothing either; he must either have arisen from, and be dependent on, something that was there previously, or have existed forever. We will all, presumably, die one day. The argument is an posteriori argument, and the conclusion is not claimed to follow with certainty. Every time she looks over her shoulder, she sees someone duck behind an object to avoid being seen. Claim: every cause has a cause but you then go on to claim that there is a first cause that has no cause. It isnt a place for us to perform or prove our worth. Proposition 1: The entire Universe came from Y. And how we understand death will dramatically change how we face it. Yeah. Many scientists assume that the universe came from nothing, which is an idea that can only be true in light of quantum theory. Nothing as only a word or sound (that is, there is no ontological referent for it even though the word can be written or spoken). Something From Nothing. John thinks that since something cannot come from nothing and since we know there was a Big Bang, an all-powerful but invisible and undetectable being must have been the cause of the Big Bang. Here is my question: Where did God come from then? Newer Than: Search this thread only; Search this forum only. This debate forum is not aligned Search titles only; Posted by Member: Separate names with a comma. Something cannot come from nothing and yet, it is at least logically possibly that something does not come from anything. One or more target certificates to verify, one per file. Why is it illogical for something to come from nothing? 1. Language is the main tool we have to communicate to others our view of reality. Display results as threads Our Universe is made of matter (rather than antimatter), obeys the same laws of physics everywhere and at all times, and began at least, as we know it with a hot Big Bang some 13.8 billion years ago. 8. I've heard the creationist arguement that something cannot come from nothing. Claim: Something cannot come from nothing and your evidence for this is what? Nothing will come of nothing. Everything was created by nothing. This apparently is not enough to stop people using the sentence "something cannot come from nothing" as if it had some metaphysical import. Next, Descartes appeals to an innate logical principle: something cannot come from nothing. I buy 12 at a time or.They immediatley have something they can connect with. But how we die, is at least somewhat, up to us. Search titles only; Posted by Member: Separate names with a comma.
Search titles only; Posted by Member: Separate names with a comma. Language therefore is far from an objective medium that simply reflects the way the world is. But that perspective is itself already shaped by the language we use. All attempts to do this remain highly speculative. 2 Kings 9 (Jezebel dies). This call is a follow-up to an e-mail discussion that can be read on the Atheist Experience Blog and Biblocality.com. We are now on our third management Company. Where did all the stuff in the universe come from and how is it still a law if it was once broken? Its a meeting-point for eBay buyers and sellers to chat, ask questions and exchange advice and tips with each other. Here too, I would like to mention that we are victims of the throwaway culture, Pope Francis said. nothing) If I understand the logic correctly [insert sarcastic eye roll here], it's not possible for something unintelligent to produce something as profoundly intelligent as God, and it is completely ludicrous that omnipresence, omniscience, and omnipotence could sprout from nothing. So we come with this baggage that is just like, yeah. Everyone talks to each other. The argument that "something cannot come from nothing" is either the first or last claim that a person will use to support theism. Second, they have to distinguish if they mean Scientific Nothing (which is still very much something, read Lawrence Krauss if you dont believe me), or Philosophical Nothing (the absence of existence). It doesn't. The argument that "something cannot come from nothing" is either the first or last claim that a person will use to support theism. But how we die, is at least somewhat, up to us. But in return for that, remember that He gives all. First, there is the issue that they must prove that something cannot come from nothing. Newer Than: Search this thread only; Search this forum only. Joined: Mar 4, 2009 Messages: 648 Likes Received: 692 #1 Et Cetera, Jul 14, 2009. Its impossible for something to come from nothing. We create different worlds using different vocabularies, even This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. Born in AZ, raised in OH, Leif was a scholarship competitive sailor for the US Naval Academy. And it's, it's so different from. I think if you accept the notion that a "spiritual being" such as Gawd must exist outside of space and time, and is not affected by laws of physics, thermodynamics etc etc, Non-existent things simply cant bring themselves into existence all on their own. Now, there are various possible responses to this, and I've engaged in a number of arguments here and elsewhere regarding this assertion. Discworld is a comic fantasy book series by British author Terry Pratchett set on the Discworld, a flat world balanced on the backs of four elephants which are in turn standing on the back of a giant turtle, the Great A'Tuin.The stories are arranged in several different story arcs that are further explained in the Wikipedia article on the Discworld reading order. Paglia referred to something: but there is the throwing away of children that we do not want to welcome, with that abortion law that sends them back to their sender and kills them, said Pope Francis. Some of us tell our children on a regular basis not to worry, because monsters do not appear underneath beds. After that, it was also by means of Blythe Noren that Blythe Fetzers incarnation of Lloyd Catt was able to disguise his own remains types of blood pressure pillsvasodilator drugs 45:08- Membership Mindset Vs. Consecration Approach. Let X=Nothing. Dr. John Lennox ( Professor in Mathematics at Oxford University) responds to this assertion that the universe can and will create itself from nothing with; That sounds to me like something out of Alice in Wonderland its not science! From nothing, nothing comes! or No-thing cannot do anything. A Dharma talk offered by Thich Nhat Hanh Berkeley Community Theater, Berkeley, California September 13, 2001. That much is certain. A cloud cannot come from nothing, so before being a cloud, it must have been something else: water in the ocean, heat from the sun, et cetera. Therefore, our first choice is answered. The second is illogical and there is no third. So that moment we call birth is not a true beginning; the cloud has not come from nothingness into being. Kants contemporaries, in different ways, J.G. By Joshua Howgego. Nothingness " is a philosophical term for the general state of nonexistence, sometimes reified as a domain or dimension into which things pass when they cease to exist or out of which they may come to exist, e.g., in some cultures God is understood to have Something did not come from nothing. Newer Than: Search this thread only; Search this forum only. Nothingness " is a philosophical term for the general state of nonexistence, sometimes reified as a domain or dimension into which things pass when they cease to exist or out of which they may come to exist, e.g., in some cultures God is understood to have created the Link: President Russell M. Nelson, Let Us All Press On, April Therefore, when this something (as a whole) cannot come from nothing, then something must have always existed and cannot have a beginning. Prayer isnt a place for us to be good or right. The quote alludes to one of the most important ideas at work in the playnothing vs. something. Some of them appeal to supernatural forces like a designer. Something did not come from nothing. The origins of the cosmological argument come from Greek philosophers Plato and Aristotle. [1] The reader might be thinking that the idea that nothing created everything from nothing is prosperous and nobody would entertain such an idea. Your client will be come with green dot in server machine. It is often claimed that something cannot come from nothing.
In fact, what exactly do you mean by nothing, how would you define that? And it's no joke and it is a community like people. G-d created the Universe and always was and always will be. We choose our words carefully to convey our perspective. You know, being an employee in a corporate where it has nothing to do with you, even if you are the one setting the price, it has nothing Janene: to do with you where here it has everything to do with you, or you think it has everything to feel it. Let Y=Something, Let T=Time. If something cannot come from nothing then where did God come from? B) Something, (i.e. The quote appears in Act I, Scene 1, line 99. Troy (aka Youtube user Parture) from Edmonton, Alberta (Canada) tries to prove the existence of God with the argument that something cannot come from nothing, as popularized by Christian apologists like William Lane Craig. If there was truly nothing, we didn't exist and neither did logic, or rules or laws. Discussion in 'Philosophy' started by Et Cetera, Jul 14, 2009. Answer (1 of 9): Why can't something come from nothing? Language therefore is far from an objective medium that simply reflects the way the world is. We can turn to five of historys most influential philosophers for wisdom, and maybe solace, as we meet our maker, writes Steven Luper. Erin feels that she is being followed. The United States of America and its European posse regularly make allegations of human rights abuses against any nation that opposes their policies in the world, resists their aggressive rules, and creates obstacles to their hegemony. There are two gates and one one of them has a call box that actually works and then only if Display results as threads Yeah. We create different worlds using different vocabularies, even though we are That is not the measurement but He does ask for allall their heart, all their might, all their mind, all their strength, all their soul. Its impossible for something to come from nothing. We don't observe that, therefore it's impossible. The way you should "deal" with any argument is by considering it carefully, finding its strong and weak points, and figuring out whether it makes sense or not. Something cannot come from nothing. A note about home projects during Coronavirus (COVID-19). The statement "something cannot come from nothing" is often brought up when the big bang is discussed and is quite puzzling. OR. When scientists say that the universe can simply come out of nothing without any divine intervention, they think of the universe in terms of its energy content only. The question of where the universe came from isnt solved by pointing to the big bang, because this begs the question of where it came from. Reasoning from this principle he arrives at two other causal principles: (1) There must be as much reality in a cause as in an effect, and so, (2) there must be as much formal reality in a cause of an idea as there is objective reality in an idea. However, this does necessarily mean that something cannot come from nothing. As one answer has already pointed out, there appears to We have helped over 100,00 patients nationwide get their medical marijuana card in over 20 states, so our experience providing this service is unmatched. Possibility A gives us the same situation as that described by standard (no quantum mechanics) Big Bang theory: a universe which exists at every instant of time and hence does not come from a prior state of nothingness. Language is the main tool we have to communicate to others our view of reality. Search titles only; Posted by Member: Separate names with a comma. The philosophical concept of nothing is related to the scientific notion of nothing, in that most scientists agree that since the universe exists, it had to have come from something. That is so cool.It's so cool. These two things are contradictory, yet they are the direct result of nothing. Nothing as only a concept (that is, it exists only in a mind). I agree Briggs, something cannot come nothing or in more specific terms, a non-existent thing cannot come into being without anything real making it happen. The axiomatic principle of cause and effect states that something cannot come from nothing, that every effect must have an adequate cause. All. And how we understand death will dramatically change how we face it. They'll come in, they'll be six people in at the cupcake and they'll be like, Oh my God, have you tried the Have you tried the retro, it's my favorite. Nothing will come of nothing. This line means that it is definite that we cannot evolve anything from where there is nothing as nothing represents that there is no thing. If we do not make any efforts, we cannot expect any good result for our endeavor. This line is taken from the play KING LEAR. Et Cetera thread killa. The argument attempts to find proof for Gods existence stating that as something cannot come from nothing God must exist in order for anything and everything else to exist. We will all, presumably, die one day. how much is a 10k silver ring worth I'm just curious to hear your thoughts/feedback on my answer. So that moment we call birth is not a true beginning; the cloud has not come from nothingness into being. Piling up massive peacetime deficits is something we havent done before. Neither do babies in our arms, or education in our minds. The axiomatic principle of cause and effect states that something cannot come from nothing, that every effect must have an adequate cause. I've also heard it asked (usually in a tone of voice which suggests a certain profundity) that something cannot come from nothing. The Lord does not care about the amount of money that we consecrate. 4.5k. But that perspective is itself already shaped by the language we use.
Welcome to the eBay Community your community.
By Deepak Chopra, MD and Pankaj S. Joshi, PhD. Lucretius made the argument that something can't come from nothing or else anything could pop into existence at any time. Image Credit: Chaoss/Shutterstock. What arguments would modern philosophers give? If you ask when something is going to be repaired they lie to you and tell you soon when they have no intention of repairing it. Answer (1 of 171): First of all, I take issue with the phrasing "how do you deal with argument X". The wristwatch that I wear on my left arm did not just happen all by itself, someone had to build it. Its a place for us to be honest, present, and knowna place for us to offer ourselves and receive God. I have often heard it asserted that something cannot come from nothing. Display results as threads If it were possible, we would observe it, because there's Therefor, logic dictates that something can't come from nothing, since "nothing" is impossible to exist. Marchesk. Reasoning from this principle he arrives at two other causal principles: (1) There must be as much reality in a cause as in an effect, and so, (2) there must be as much formal reality in a cause of an idea as there is objective reality in an idea. Thomas' Argument from Necessity begins with a number of empirical observations including the premise that contingent objects in the world come into existence and pass away. This is because, if nothing exists, then: 1) There is no potentiality for a universe to exist 2) There is no potentiality for a universe not to exist. a non-intelligent thing) C) Nothing, (i.e. Wavefunctions describe something, not nothing. We cannot know the full consequences.Of course, Trump proposes some good ideas. 2 Kings 6:1518 (They that be with us are more than they that be with them). This call is a follow-up to an e-mail discussion that can be read on the Atheist Experience Blog and Biblocality.com. My father who is a mechanical engineer seems to think that something cannot come from nothing but I think that he is wrong because my father evidently never heard of virtual particles and quantum field theory. Next, Descartes appeals to an innate logical principle: something cannot come from nothing. Michel de Montaigne. Possibility B gives us a universe extending back infinitely in time. 2. Often this is just a colloquial formulation of the conservation of energy, however, it is also used as some sort of metaphysical intuition as a defense of certain premises in logical arguments regarding beginnings. NO QUESTION is more sublime than why there is a Universe: why there is anything rather than nothing, philosopher Derek Joined: Mar 4, 2009 Messages: 648 Likes Received: 692 #1 Et Cetera, Jul 14, 2009.
